Ramban on Vayeira - Sedom and Pilegesh baGiv'a

Ramban has a lengthy comment comparing the story of Sodom to the story of the Concubine at Giveah. This shiur explores those parallels and raises questions about the various parties involved. Beyond the specific elements that are unique to both stories, they each involve a corrupt society. In the case of Sodom, God destroys the city, but in the case of Giveah, the rest of the tribes band together to wage war against Binyamin. But was this the right thing to do? Did they properly consult with God? When a society has a problem within it, it is the responsibility of that society to fix it. The story about Giveah is a tragedy wherein none of the survivors are blameless. Before embarking on something as severe as civil war, the parties involved must seriously and carefully determine whether it is something that God wants.